Schick Vs. Gillette Men’s Razors: What’s the Difference and Which is Better?

Gillette versus Schick. Which is the better brand to shave?

When it comes to shaving, there are plenty of companies out there that sell razors. But perhaps the two biggest names in razors are a couple of companies that have seemingly been around forever: Gillette and Schick.

Combined, these two brands have about 60% of the razor industry, with Gillette boasting about half the market and Schick coming in with about 10%, according to news reports.

If you don’t pay as close attention to razors and shaving as we do, you might be wondering exactly what the difference is between these two major brands. More importantly, which is the better razor for your shave?

Below, we highlight some of the differences between each and give you our thoughts on which we like better.

Gillette Is Owned By Procter & Gamble; Schick Is Owned By Edgewell

As with many brands these days, both Gillette and Schick are owned by much larger companies.

Gillette is part of Procter & Gamble, the conglomerate that owns some of the world’s most famous household names like Downy, Tide, Charmin, and Head & Shoulders. The razor brand was bought by P&G back in 2005.

Schick is part of the Edgewell Personal Care lineup. While Edgewell is not quite the household name of Procter & Gamble, it owns a number of famous names, including Hawaiian Tropic, Playtex, Wet Ones, and Banana Boat.

If you’re looking to support an independent razor manufacturer, they seem to be getting more rare. Dollar Shave Club is now owned by Unilever. Harry’s was set to be acquired by Edgewell before the deal was blocked by the Federal Trade Commission. As of now, it’s still an independent company.

Gillette Offers a Larger Lineup of Razors

When it comes to refillable safety razors, Schick offers three options — Hydro 3, Quattro Titanium, and Hydro 5. Gillette offers considerably more options for you to choose.

This includes the Mach3, Fusion5, the Fusion ProGlide, SkinGuard, as well as a number of other variations, including handles with powered vibration.

That’s not to say having fewer options means you won’t find a razor you like from Schick. In fact, one of our favorites comes from the brand. However, if you’re someone that likes you have lots of options, then Gillette is the clear leader in the field.

Schick’s Hydro 5 Offers More Lubrication

Hydro 5 Sense razor cartridge

To be sure, no razor we’ve tested from either Gillette or Schick is lacking when it comes to lubrication. It’s more of a matter of personal comfort. Some people appreciate lubrication that only adds a little slickness to help the razor move easier. Others like lots of thick lubrication that provides a shave you don’t really feel.

In our experience, the Schick Hydro 5 (shown above) offers more — and thicker — lubrication than anything we’ve tested from Gillette. The Hydro 5 features seven “gel pools” across the top. As you shave (especially your first few shaves) the lubrication goes on heavy and the razor glides easily across your face.

If you’re someone that enjoys lots of slickness in your shave, then you might appreciate the Hydro 5.

Schick Offers Razors Made in the USA

On Razorist, we’ve reviewed dozens of blades, but very few are made in the United States. Razors are made around the world, including Germany, Mexico, Poland, South Korea and more.

In fact, one of the only razors we’ve found that’s made in the United States comes on the Schick Hydro 5. The handle is made in China, but the actual razor cartridge is made in the United States. (The Schick Quattro is made in Germany.) We’ve found that many of the Gillette razors we’ve tested are made in Mexico.

If buying American is important to you, the Hydro 5 is one of the only options you have.

Gillette’s Flexball versus Schick’s Shock Absorb

Pivoting head of the razor

Today’s razors are the most complex ever made, with more features than ever. And the technology has moved well beyond just adding more blades to the razor head.

Perhaps the most visible sign of advancement is in the pivoting in today’s blades. Heads that move back and forth a little to go around the curves of your face have been around for a long time. Now, pivoting is moving to the handle.

Gillette offers the Flexball, which pivots left and right on the handle to give an additional range of motion in shaving. It’s definitely unique among razors we’ve tested.

As an answer to the Flexball, Schick offers “Shock Absorb” technology. While the razor cartridge pivots back and forth as you’ll find on any other razor, there is also another pivoting point built into the handle. Thus, there is a sort of “dual action” pivot on the head.

Schick’s Quattro Titanium Is The Only Razor We’ve Seen With Unique “Wire Wraps”

Razor head on the Schick Quattro Titanium

There are lots of advancements in shaving where one company comes out with a feature and others mimic that design.

One unique thing we’ve found is that the Schick Quattro Titanium offers tiny wires that go over the edge of the razors. In the photo above you’ll see seven strands that run over the face of the blades.

We’ve never seen this on other razors from either Schick or Gillette. Why does it matter?

In our review of the Schick Quattro, we found that these wires help to keep the blades from direct contact with the face, meaning it still cut close but also felt amazingly smooth when making a pass.

Does Gillette or Schick Make Better Razors?

Given they are the two biggest names in shaving, many people want to know which brand makes a better razor.

While we haven’t tried every razor from both companies, we have tried a number from each, including the Schick’s Quattro and Hydro 5, as well as Gillette’s Fusion5 and ProGlide.

So which is better?

To be sure, if you have hair on your face, either one of them will give you a nice, smooth shave. In our testing, however, we’ve been more impressed with the design and quality of Gillette razors.

For one, Gillette seems to put a lot of thought into the design of the handle and cartridge. From the shape of the handle, which includes narrow and wider points for better grip, to the positioning of the rubber grips (and even the texture of the grip in certain places where people are likely to grab the handle), it’s obvious that a lot of thought goes into the design.

Furthermore, every razor from the brand that we’ve reviewed has felt high quality. There are no rattles or loose parts. When the razor head pivots, it springs back into place as soon as pressure is released. To us, the razors feel like the Mercedes of shaving.

Beyond that, the shaves we’ve had with Gillette products are also near perfection. We never have tugging, pulling, or snags. Even a couple of days’ growth is easily shaved without having to go over sections again and again. Each shave is smooth, as you’d hope it would be.

Gillette also gets marks for consistently pushing new features like the Flexball and a powered handle.

Now, this isn’t to say that the Schick razors we’ve tried don’t offer a good shave. They certainly do. However, in our opinion the Gillette options just do things slightly better overall. For example, we found the Hydro 5 “Shock Absorb” feature to be distracting and there was a slight about of “play” in the handle and razor connection that made it feel lower quality.

The Schick Quattro Titanium — despite being a “simpler” razor — is one of our favorites for its great comfort when shaving. Even so, we’d still choose Gillette Fusion over the Quattro.

Bottom line: Both offer good shaves with no tugging, pulling, nicks or cuts. But if you asked us to choose which we thought was better, then the Gillette razors we’ve tested would be the clear leader.

6 COMMENTS

  1. I have both the Schick Hydro 5 & the Gillette Proglide. I purchased the Proglide because I could not get more than a few shaves from the Hydro 5 before it became dull and I went through several packs of cartridges. The “smoothness” is lost when it feels like you have to rip hairs out to get a close shave. After 11 smooth & close shaves with the Proglide, the blades seem sharp enough for at least 10 more rounds before I may have to change the cartridge. For me, the Proglide is a far better razor.

  2. I am bodybuilder and I shave my entire body. I’ve tried Gilette, Shick, Harrys, Dollar Shave, Dorco plus a handful of others.
    Although I like the build of Gillette and Dollar Shave the best, nothing I’ve ever tried comes close to Shick Hydro 5. For one, it just “glides” better. Secondly, lets say I’ve went 4 or so days without shaving my chest and stomach for example, with the Schick, when I take a stroke with the blade, it can get it one “swipe” that it takes Gillette or the others 4 swipes with rinse in between to get the same amount of hair. So basically, the shave is smother and takes about half as many (or less) passes with the Schick, which equates to a much quicker shave. I think all of the razors I listed do a great job….it just some take way more passes than Schick. I like the design of some of the others. I WISH the others were better than Schick actually, but they aren’t.

  3. I live in Australia and have used Gillette since I started shaving at 16, (I am 51 now, so a very long time). Over the years I have tried to use other shavers to see if I can get a comfortable, smooth shave, for at least 1-2 days. Each time I bought other brands the first 5-10 shaves were comparable but after this the delta in performance was significant! My Gillette Fusion 5 Power comfortably gives me 20 shaves (3 shaves per week, Mon/Wed/Fri’s, over 6 weeks) with no pulling and little to no reduction in gliding over the skin. Each and every time I have tried other products I go back to a tried and tested formulae for success, which Gillette seems to have mastered. The cost per blade is important, but it doesn’t matter if you shaver doesn’t perform each week. On top of this I like to trial new Shaving Gels/Creams/Oils and supposed “FOG proof” mirrors for the shower/bath. This has been a lifelong project but I still haven’t found the perfect combination to give me that “perfect” shaving experince…but it is getting close! Thanks for reading my review, I hope it helps other seeking the “Perfect Shave”

  4. The Schick Hydro 5 blades ARE crafted in the US, but are made of imported Chinese steel… so to come out and say that the cartridges, which include the Blades, are made here in the USA is BUNK and misleading. The Blades as they say on their packaging are “honed and crafted in the USA.” What a crock… and somewhat misleading, again, as the metal is imported from China, and then “honed and crafted” here.
    Can’t believe we cannot make even simple razors – complete – here at home in the USA.

  5. To hell with Gillette; get a straight razor, learn how to sharpen it for the best shave ever. I’ll be damned if I give one cent the the company that made the commercial about abusive men, and the ones depicted “saving” everyone from them. They needed to reverse who was doing what to whom, but oh yeah, they weren’t brave enough to tell the truth.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here